About LS.n


 
 

Review: Steely Dan's 'Two Against Nature'
by Jordan Hoffman

published 3/13/00

REVIEWS HOME




Jordan Hoffman is LeisureSuit.net's Queens-based Senior Editor.



MOST RECENT YAK ABOUT THIS ARTICLE:

Subj: Review: Steely Dan's two Against Nature
C'mon, gang. "Waxing her skis" refers to her legs. This doesn't take place at a mountain lodge.

-- Christopher Fenger
Mar 10, 2007 at 2:49PM

Read more or post your own





Be cool like us!
Are you getting our weekly update?





It's GOOD to share!
E-mail this article to a buddy

To anyone who thought that Steely Dan couldn't be relevant in 2000, I have news for you: they were never relevant.

To anyone who thought Steely Dan would've lost their outsider's wit and poisonous sarcasm by 2000, I offer the opening line from "Gaslighting Abbie," the first track on their triumphant comeback album Two Against Nature: "One plush summer you come to me ripe and ready and bad through and through, with that deep mystical soul synergy pumping steady between me and you."

Placement of the word "synergy" has nothing to do with needing three syllables. "Synergy" is the perfect word, the angry word, the word that, if you're paying attention, shades the rest of the phrase with the perspective of the modern day millionaire, the fin de millennium mogul, the hopeless empty suit cum empty soul . . . you know, the guy Steely Dan has been singing about since "Can't Buy A Thrill." "Synergy" is just the sort of word an establishment rock band would use in a vapid Adult Contemporary song, especially one with such well-arranged horns, so The Dan thought they could sneak it in below the radar. As William Gibson noted in a surprisingly readable ATN article, only Becker and Fagen can give you the special surreal moment of hearing a song about a middle-aged Scarsdale man coking up before a night of hymen-busting playing softly in the background on the Shop-Rite PA system.

And finally, to anyone who thinks two old Jewish farts from New York can't craft the perfect song anymore, well, hell, let's just go down the list of all nine.

"Two Against Nature" opens with the aforementioned "Gaslighting Abbey." The unmistakable Dan-ish beat, the pasteurized funk, the groove to perfection. Becker himself handles the thumping bass and tickling guitar fills. If this isn't soul music, then nothing is. Like about half of the Dan's collected work, I have no idea what this song is about on an explicit level. Emotionally, it represents utter perfectionism, a perfect opening track.

"What A Shame About Me," apart from hitting home about an NYU graduate not fulfilling his dreams while his classmates excel, maintains the groove, but, more importantly, is the album's first example of the "golden chord progression" patented by The Dan ever since "Katy Lied." Fagen hits the high nasal notes, harmonizing with three learned female backups. High point memory: "A major Jane Street sunrise and the goddess on the fire escape was you." Current truth: "Alan owns a chain of Steamer Heavens, and Barry is a software King."

"Two Against Nature's" title track opens with some squeaking sax, a bossa-nova beat, a jabbed-out piano riff, and layers of horn, bass and percussion. I have no clue what this song is about, but I think it has something to do with odd religious ceremonies. It's one of the most rhythm-heavy songs in the Dan's entire catalogue. The horns fill in Zappa-"Hot Rats" style, and Becker's leads are well-spaced. I think there's a wurlitzer in here, too, but there's so much going on I can't be sure. Also, something the hushing power of sprinkled chicken water.

"Janie Runaway," picking up where Steven Soderbergh's The Limey leaves off, slams down a Stax-era bass-thump. A whimsical Fagen falsetto asks "Who makes the morning fabulous?" It's the wonder-waif of Grammercy Park, an underage runway-runaway, gallivanting with rich old men, leaving her worried parents in North Florida. She has a friend named Melanie, she grabs take out from Dean and Deluca (I guess Mr. Chow's is out-of-date?) She spends a weekend up at Binky's place, she'll make the traffic interesting, she'll spend her birthday in Spain-—possibly. Possibly? You mean, Janie's not the first!!! Chris Potter's alto solo comes on like a taunting laugh at this revelation, then comes to a shocking halt. At Four minutes and eight seconds, it's by far the shortest cut on the album, perhaps the most biting.

"Almost Gothic," is just a beautiful melody, reminiscent of "Deacon Blue" or "Your Gold Teeth II." The horns puff quietly in a Bacharach mode, the changes surprise, the liquid Rhodes cools, Fagen croons as best he can ("I'm sizzling like an Isotope.") Straight-forward, it's all about a special girl ("first she's all feel, then she cools down, she's pure science with a splash of black cat.") It's classic, timeless, in that 1965 way they did it back in 1974. I see zoom lenses, lots and lots of zoom lenses.

"Jack of Speed," a mid-tempo groove which would have felt right at home toward the end of side two on "The Royal Scam," may be the most straight-ahead rocker. I can see someone who claims not to like Steely Dan admitting that this cut is less than atrocious. The Jack himself is a shrouded figure, one last attempt on Becker & Fagen's part to evoke Dean Moriarity. Becker cuts loose with one of the slickest solos of his recorded career.

"Cousin Dupree," already a classic, weaves the yarn about the scrappy (ex-keyboardist in a rock n' ska band) sleeping on his Aunt's couch, lusting after his blooming cousin. Well, they used to play when they were three, so why not a kiss from her Cousin Dupree? He does his his best to read the National Globe, but with all the washing of skis, well, you know how that goes. Drummer Leroy Clouden gets mad props for laying down the most solid of beats to Becker's bass-funk. There's some crazy instrument called a whistler buzzing around on here, too.

"Negative Girl," the most complex track on the album, opens in some wild fusion space. Becker sub-contracts guitar and bass duties to Dean Parks, Paul Jackson Jr. and Tom Barney respectively. They get a little Metheny on our collective asses, and the vocal melody ventures off a bit into dissonance. Lots of sheet music scattered around the studio on this one, vocal harmonies shooting for something difficult here. Subject matter's appropriate, and strangely to familiar: the difficult love of a "difficult girl," with her doctors uptown and crying on the phone. I'm not sure if this song totally succeeds, but God bless The Dan for trying.

"West of Hollywood" closes the album out much like "King of The World" did on "Countdown To Ecstacy." A fast and furious beat, transposed keys all over the place, building and building and permutating all the time. Chris Potter takes the most extended no-holds barred jazz solo on a Dan tune since Wayne Shorter did on "Aja." Just as painterly is the evocation of spiritual death on the left coast. "I'm way deep into nothings special, riding the crest of a wave breaking just west of Hollywood." It's a wicked vision, Potter's furious solo fades us out . . . leaving us, where?

Steely Dan will surely tour and tour big in support of this brilliant album. Will they then disappear for nineteen more years? I don't think so. The Becker and Fagen solo albums of the ninetines--which, by the way, I used to think were good enough, but pale in comparison to "Two Against Nature"--were just test drives to get the groove back. And it's back. When there's this much talent, you can't keep it bottled in for nineteen years and expect only one release. It's gonna' get fun.


Your name:

Subject:


Comments:

Forward a copy of this yak to the LS.n Editors

Forward a copy of this yak to this article's author

If you want to get an e-mail if someone responds to your yak, give us your address below. It won't be made public.

THE YAK SHACK


Name: Christopher Fenger
Subject: Review: Steely Dan's two Against Nature
-- Mar 10, 2007 at 2:49PM
C'mon, gang. "Waxing her skis" refers to her legs. This doesn't take place at a mountain lodge.

Name: Berlinda
Subject: Review: Steely Dan's Two Against Nature
-- Dec 5, 2005 at 5:17PM
I am in love with this CD and am playing it at work and realized, as usual, I'm never really sure what the songs are about so I thought I'd look up Gaslighting Abbie and see what I hit. Not much but this site was interesting. I always like to hear what other people have to say. I turned a friend of mine, who is a major SD fan (so he says), on to this CD because I love it so much and he did NOT! I don't see where this is much different from any other great SD recording, but he didn't think it sounded like the "old SD"!! Jeeze! What SD is HE listing to?? Doesn't look like this site is much visited?? Interesting! GO SD GO...MORE MORE MORE!!

Name: Bruce
Subject: Review: Steely Dan's 'Two Against Nature'
-- Oct 3, 2003 at 9:43AM
Fagan is Morman, yes LDS.
When he refers to the green book, it's the book of Mormon, genius.
But then what does it matter, you pathetic, slimy, antisemite?

Name: Bruce
Subject: Review: Steely Dan's 'Two Against Nature'
-- Oct 3, 2003 at 9:40AM
Fagan is Morman, yes LDS.
When he refers to the green book, it's the book of Mormon, genius.
But then what does it matter, you pathetic, slimy, antisemite?

Name: Jordan Hoffman Responds
Subject: Re: Sue's assumptions
-- Sep 27, 2003 at 5:41PM
Walter Becker and Donald Fagen are both Jewish.

Name: Mo
Subject: Sue's assumptions
-- Sep 23, 2003 at 4:35PM
I don't know if Becker is Jewish or not, but just being German doesn't mean he isn't. Fritz Lang, Peter Lorre, Albert Einstein, and Sigmund Freud all come to mind as Jews raised as cultural Germans. Sue needs some brain-tuning, if you ask me.

Name: Sue
Subject: 2vN review
-- Mar 15, 2001 at 5:14PM
I get the feeling the author is trying to be analytical here, but has no clue about Steely Dan's use of characters.

The review's whole breakdown of "synergy" is waaaay off. The character is speaking, not SD. The character is a pathetic jerk who is working with his new evil girlfriend to drive his wife crazy- watch the classic movie "Gaslight" and you'll get it.

Becker is not Jewish, he's German. Tom Sweet's book about SD mentions how Fagan said Becker kicked his drug problems with nothing but "Bavarian will-power".

"Jack of Speed" evoking Dean Moriarity? The tune's a warning to a girl to dump a drug addicted guy.

"Negative Girl" is not just about a difficult girl, it's about a cokehead chick. It echoes "Black Cow" from Aja.

I feel like the author is trying too hard to sound smart, and think he should stick to writing what he knows about- whatever THAT night be. It's not Steely Dan.


Name: tzf
Subject: Jordan's sloppy review
-- Jul 3, 2000 at 10:44PM
Jordan's review is nice, but sloppy on the details. Janey gets to go to spain for her birthday IF: her freind Melanie comes along for some weekend fun and is open-minded to "try new things". Scurrolous! Gaslighting Abbie is about two plotting murder against a third (look up "Gaslight" on IMDB.com). And Cousin Dupree is reading the National Globe, he's reading the national PROBE, much more suggestive, especially with the confluence of the mental image of a buxom gal WAXING (not washing) her skis... have you ever seen someone waxing her skis? First she stretches aaalll the way UP... then she bends ALLLL the way OVER... ooh, like Cousin Dupree, "all I can say is OW - OW - OUCH!" -tzf

Name: Phil
Subject: Breath of fresh air
-- May 30, 2000 at 10:48PM
This recording falls perfectly in sequence with the last SD works, despite the intervening years. All the hallmarks - the ascerbic lyrics, imaginative charts, and state-of-the-art playing, are all present. And like their other offerings, this one only gets better with each listening.

Only bone to pick with Jordan's excellent review is his view of "Negative Girl". To my ears, this track stands out as the next-level iteration of the SD songwriting craft, comparable to the achievement of the title track "Aja" in its time. It is rich beyond anything they have previously attempted, and I simply cannot get it out of my head. Clearly, the hilight of the recording for me.

A must-have CD.

Name: Stephen
Subject: Steely Reflections
-- May 24, 2000 at 6:18PM
Only a Steely Dan fan understands when he (or she?) is communicating with another. I've been listening since the 70's when they played in Joplin, MO and, with typical arrogance, simply left the sitar part out on "Do It Again" and told the audience to go to hell when they complained. (It was also loud enough to burst a few eardrums.) I saw the TV special and now, with this, I'm in the car on my way to get the C.D. Who knows, maybe even my 19 year old female student assistant may come to be affected by "Two Against Nature."

Name: Chris
Subject: Welcome back
-- Apr 4, 2000 at 9:49PM
Great article. I thought that the interpertations of the songs were pretty accurate. Janie Runaway is the best track, WoH a close second, then NG.

Name: Roy
Subject: PBS
-- Mar 17, 2000 at 6:19AM
Great special with classics and the new "Two Against Nature".
"Cousin Dupree" kicks! All still with the 70's style I still love today; I hate bands that come back and sound like someone else due to falling prey to what the current market dictates. Two masters that I'm glad I have been lucky enough to hear again. I have to leave to pick up "Two Against Nature"!!!
Roy
PS
Check it out and ENJOY!
Make your kids listen to it before NSYNC and C.A. and Brit. Spears destroy their minds!!! LOLOLOLOL!!!


This page is best viewed with the latest version of the Netscape or Microsoft Internet Explorer browser.

© Copyright 1998-2001 LeisureSuit Media, LLC, All Rights Reserved.
Some content is copyrighted by the author and is used with permission. No portion of this page or its content may be reproduced, in part or in whole, electronically, in print, or in any other form or by any other means, without the written consent of the LeisureSuit.net editors. Contact us at webmaster@leisuresuit.net.
[an error occurred while processing this directive]