About LS.n


 
 

Review: Modest Mouse 'The Moon & Antarctica'
by Jordan Hoffman

published 7/3/00

REVIEWS HOME




Jordan Hoffman is LeisureSuit.net's Queens-based Senior Editor.



MOST RECENT YAK ABOUT THIS ARTICLE:

Subj: Re: theirrrrrrr great
opps.. this is about 5 years after writing that first post.. boy and i an idiot.. let the record be set straight.. im glad modest mouse is doing great.

-- Tyler Fluharty
Dec 16, 2007 at 10:43PM

Read more or post your own





Be cool like us!
Are you getting our weekly update?





It's GOOD to share!
E-mail this article to a buddy

Modest Mouse
I want to make this quick, because every critic with ink in his pen has set their sites on Modest Mouse as the last, great shot at saving rock and roll. I doubt they’ll ever have widespread appeal, but I do recognize The Moon & Antarctica as a breakthrough record in the mold of R.E.M.’s “Document” and Nirvana’s “Nevermind.”

For those that have not heard Modest Mouse, these two goalposts (wide ones, at that) may be quite helpful. Modest Mouse, a midwestern trio, follow quite well the code of the scruffy, underground, intelligent outsider. They exude the same sort of artful slack that was virtually created by R.E.M and groups like The Minutemen. The lyrics are vague, but vaguely beautiful, vaguely important (‘The Moon & Antarctica” can fight with the Flaming Lips’ Soft Bulletin as most cosmic record in the post-Yes era.) The mention of Nirvana is simple: Modest Mouse rock.

“A Different City” opens with a sick wailing riff, followed by the angry chant “I want to look out the window of my color TV!” “Tiny Cities Made of Ashes” features a Talking Heads-style bass and rubber band-snap guitar noises, as well as the concert-ready sing-along line “We’re drinkin’ drinkin’ drinkin’ drinkin’ coca coca coca cola!”

Most of the songs have a tendency to space out toward the end, but Modest Mouse are strict about their hesitency to jam. They’d much rather experiment with chord changes, flanging effects, use of cello and other strings. “Dark Center of the Universe” reaches is spooky, Syd Barret-era Floyd-style conclusion just by getting faster and faster.

Modest Mouse may resemble the great Prog masters lyrically, their delivery, heavily rooted in the indie aesthetic, saves them from any whiff of pretension. That said, “The Stars are Projectors” does end with the repeated line “Where do circles begin?” I believe that Modest Mouse’s foremost intentions are to rock and rock hard. Then, to rock interestingly. Then, to whip out their post-grad Vogon poetry on us all.

I could be wrong. I am not a Modest Mouse expert. I’ve heard the name for a number of years, but even I can’t keep up with everybody. I foolishly filed them in my mind as clones of groups like Built To Spill and the Brian Jonestown Massacre. This was foolish on my part, as “The Moon & Antarctica” proves that these guys are quite looking forward to carving a space for themselves on some Roger Dean-inspired Rushmore of rock and roll.


Your name:

Subject:


Comments:

Forward a copy of this yak to the LS.n Editors

Forward a copy of this yak to this article's author

If you want to get an e-mail if someone responds to your yak, give us your address below. It won't be made public.

THE YAK SHACK


Name: Tyler Fluharty
Subject: Re: theirrrrrrr great
-- Dec 16, 2007 at 10:43PM
opps.. this is about 5 years after writing that first post.. boy and i an idiot.. let the record be set straight.. im glad modest mouse is doing great.

Name: Tyler Fluharty
Subject: Re: theirrrrrrr great
-- Dec 16, 2007 at 10:41PM
hey its tyler fluharty again, reading this a few years later, I'm just laughing at myself.. I'm happy for modest mouse's success to set the record straight, and they are poets... music is poetry so I don't know why I bothered making that point. If i ran into myself when I wrote this.. I'd have to kick my own ass.

Name: Malcolm
Subject: richeous rat
-- Aug 19, 2006 at 6:55PM
As long as they keep making awesome albums, (not a bad one to date) let's not worry about main-stream, indie, obscure, ect. Bottom line is they can kick ass. and Isaac Brock's getting kind of fat, which probably means he's not on quite as much speed.

Name: dave
Subject: RE: NOLAN
-- Jul 25, 2005 at 2:07AM
uh, wrong album, buddy.

Float on is on "goods news . . . .", not M&A.

Both are great albums.

U suck.

Name: Kevin
Subject: Not Mainstream
-- Mar 25, 2005 at 3:38PM
How is the new album really mainstream? I mean I can see float on and a few others as being mainstream but cmon... "Gonna take this sack of puppies, gonna set it out to freeze..."

Name: Nolan
Subject: modesty in the mouse
-- Feb 18, 2005 at 10:40PM
FLOAT ON... FLOAT ON...FLOAT ON. Yes its a great sone but its just like the dumbass DJ's to replay the same songs from extremly talented bands and just wasted away some of their other recordings that could make it huge if given the chance

Name: laserus
Subject: Umm. FRICKEN YEAH
-- Jan 14, 2005 at 8:14PM
Ok i would like to say that i am totally in love with this band. And i am pisssed off that the radio only plays some of thier songs.(like fricken 2) Because most of thier music kicks fucking ass and think that it needs to be played more often. And even though they play the same song over and over again i dont even get tired of it. And Isaac has the best voice in the world...mmmmm my God! Its fucking the best thing ever.

Name: josh
Subject: exactly
-- Aug 24, 2004 at 7:29PM
Yeah, I know what you're saying about them playin that same fuckin song, ALL the time!! I don't even listen to the radio much, except when I'm with a friend or something, and I hear it at least once EVERY time!

Name: Vishnu
Subject: Review: Modest Mouse 'The Moon & Antarctica'
-- Aug 21, 2004 at 10:16PM
Ever since i was a wee little child, Modest Mouse was the thing that kept me from dropping out of school. Even though Isaac Brock was on drugs for much of his life and never went to college, I didn't want to end up like that, even if his music kicks ass. But now that this new cd is pop, I want to be so much more like him: Dropping out of school, popping acid, tricking reporters into thinking that my band members and I ran over dogs for fun.

Name: jesus`
Subject: dissapointing
-- Aug 21, 2004 at 10:11PM
THIS NEW STUFF SUCKS. DOWN WITH GOOD CUBANS FOR PEOPLE WHO LOVE BAD CUBANS.

Name: josh 2
Subject: hoorah
-- Jul 21, 2004 at 10:49PM
Well, i can't turn on the radio without hearing "Float on" every fifteen minutes, which is makes me laugh looking back at the early posts saying they'll never make it main stream. Its a shame, cause i don't think any of the other songs on Good News for People who love bad news will get any airplay, and they'll just fade back into indie obscurity. Lets hope so.

Name: josh
Subject: it's good but bad
-- Jun 26, 2004 at 4:57PM
man, they got infected by the mainstream crowd! everyone at school is all like, have you heard of that new band modest mouse? they've been around for 11 fucking years! well, anyways...if it's what they wanted, congradulations! if not, that sucks! i will always love them, though!

Name: charles
Subject: Review: Modest Mouse 'The Moon & Antarctica'
-- May 19, 2004 at 11:35PM
the time has come for modest mouse to be on mtv and such.

Name: Joelle
Subject: Review: Modest Mouse 'The Moon & Antarctica'
-- Oct 27, 2003 at 8:46PM
just that their awsome and unique... and keep it comin

Name: tyler fluharty
Subject: theirrrrrrr great
-- May 30, 2003 at 12:06AM
i would just like to say that modest mouse is my favorite band and that I have been listening to them for quite some time, i love their music, as it is different than everything else, and i would like to say that if modest mouse ever wanted to write poetry, they would be famous. but about this radio thing, i hope modest mouse is never played on the radio, and i do believe the band feels the same way. the last thing i want is to see modest mouse shirts at hot topic, that would make me sick. just picture looking around your school and seeing six kids wearing the same modest mouse shirt, when they havent ever really even listened to the band. so just think about what u say before u say they should be on the radio.

Name: Marg
Subject: incredible
-- Jul 23, 2001 at 4:02AM
Modest Mouse rocks. The way this album was put together is amazing. Each song fits in it's own place perfectly. However I do not think it will make it into the mainstream...but you never know. I hope the band makes it as far as they want to go.

Name: Samir
Subject: Review: Modest Mouse 'The Moon & Antarctica'
-- Jul 25, 2000 at 11:49AM
The Mouse is in the House

Name: HAB
Subject: mm
-- Jul 20, 2000 at 12:24PM
If you want proof that rock ain't totally headed toward a dead end, listen to this record. It's tuneful, adventurous, and even beautiful at times. I just wish there were more rock acts you could say this about today.

Name: Jake
Subject: Bad-ass record
-- Jul 10, 2000 at 9:57PM
I've been listening to Modest Mouse since their second LP, Lonesome Crowded West. Their subject matter is all that new, and what they say about it has been said quite a bit by a lot of other bands. (For clarification, their message seems to be "Goddamn the world is fucked, and the suburbs are eating everything up, and I really don't like myself very much.")

That being said, Modest Mouse is probably the best band to say all those things. Issac Brock's wonderfully lipsy voice and his smart-ass-intellectual-with-bad-case-of-ennui lyrics are fantastic. Eric Judy's bass work is always interesting, never content to stay on the three note variations that so many other indie bands do. And Jeremy Davis simply beats the living shit out of his drums.

What mystifies me is that Epic went into this bidding war to pick up Modest Mouse, and now that they have them, they make no attempts to market them. While Modest Mouse certainly isn't mainstream, I think college students would eat this stuff up. And don't tell me that "A Different City" couldn't easily be on mainstream radio, albeit on the weird DJ's midnight show. While indie hipsters are already jumping on Modest Mouse for getting too "studio", I wish the boys the best of luck.

Name: andrew
Subject: awesome
-- Jul 6, 2000 at 5:01PM
This album is amazingly artistic and beautiful, but i doubt that it will break through into the mainstream. It will likely create a large cult following, but the radio isn't smart enough to play modest mouse. Wait, it's not that the readio isn't smart enough, but people just don't have good taste in music anymore. The older generations do, but not the youth. I'm sixteen years old, and i'm one of the few teenagers with music tastes that haven't been tainted by mtv and carson daly.


This page is best viewed with the latest version of the Netscape or Microsoft Internet Explorer browser.

© Copyright 1998-2001 LeisureSuit Media, LLC, All Rights Reserved.
Some content is copyrighted by the author and is used with permission. No portion of this page or its content may be reproduced, in part or in whole, electronically, in print, or in any other form or by any other means, without the written consent of the LeisureSuit.net editors. Contact us at webmaster@leisuresuit.net.