About LS.n


 
 

Review: Ben Folds Five's 'The Unauthorized Biography of Reinhold Messner'
by Jody Beth Rosen

published 7/12/99

REVIEWS HOME



Jody Beth Rosen is a contributor to LeisureSuit.net based in Brooklyn.



MOST RECENT YAK ABOUT THIS ARTICLE:

Subj: messner
he is stilll alive in every story explaing the fake i d's ive ever read no one seems to know if he is.....welll he is; he is 54 and a well established mountaineer

-- josh
Dec 6, 2002 at 2:35AM

Read more or post your own





Be cool like us!
Are you getting our weekly update?





It's GOOD to share!
E-mail this article to a buddy

Reinhold Messner
I can't let the year go by without throwing out a few lines of opinion on Ben Folds Five's latest album, The Unauthorized Biography of Reinhold Messner. Strangely enough, I almost let this review go -- I got the album too far after its release date, and was having too much fun listening to it as a fan to want to sit down and criticize it.

Looking back at my recent music reviews, though, many of which mourn the loss of poetry, inspiration, oomph in modern pop music, I decided to put my money where my text is. I decided to write about something I actually do like, something that not only occupies a snug and warm place in my CD player, but that makes me sing along, read the lyric sheet, listen for certain drum fills and bass figures. Ben Folds Five, that most unpredictable of bands, has made the album I'd predicted it could make (but probably wouldn't): a hard rock masterpiece (okay, "masterpiece" is a journalistic crutch these days, but find me a better word and I'll give you a cookie) with no guitars, and one that draws from a stupendous range of pre-rock and non-rock sources.

"Reinhold Messner" starts with "Narcolepsy," which right away offers up musical references to Queen, Wings and Todd Rundgren, and by the time the drums come raging in at the chorus, it's obvious the band is so much more than a '70s tribute act. The sound revolves around pianist Ben Folds' enthusiastic tenths, and it's a stunning, expansive, clean sound that, when played fast, is dripping with Jerry Lee Lewis damage, and when in slow, shuffle mode, bows to Randy Newman. "Don't Change Your Plans" is a step towards seriousness from a band that sings of nose rings, mosh pits, and of girls who look like Axl Rose. Even though I appreciate Folds' ability to take a piss at himself in spite of his great talent, I'm always a little saddened that he has to do it on record ("Messner"'s "Army" is the weakest track, and the lyrics are a pastiche of Gen-X buzzwords like "screenplay," "band," "artistic differences," and "get it done yesterday.") "Don't Change Your Plans" is a straightforward love song, a yearning for independence and a sense of place ("the leaves are falling back east/that's where I want to stay.")

Even their goofiness is getting better, surprisingly. On their last album, "Whatever and Ever Amen," the clever-guy shtick was nearly relentless, with lyrics like "give me my money back, you bitch/and don't forget to give me back my black t-shirt" (from "Song For The Dumped") casting a nasty vibe over an album with some otherwise pretty tunes. On "Messner," Ben Folds Five starts off with a side of serious ballads (including the loud/soft/loud power-ballad "Narcolepsy") and earns its listeners' trust before bringing out the jokes. "Your Redneck Past" asks, "Who do you wanna be/Billy Idol or Kool Moe Dee?" over a staccato piano/bass/drums machine-gun beat, and adds, "Roots/the funny limbs that grow underground/they keep you from falling down/don't ya think that ya need 'em now?"

The most startling thing about "Reinhold Messner" is the Pink Floyd homage at the end of "Regrets" (an uptempo jazz-rock piece with a multi-octave bass line leading the way.) What's startling? Well, you try to write a song (or a piece of a song) that can be played as a sort of blindfold-test, as it were, along with "Dark Side of the Moon" -- and write it without any guitars. Add strings, fuzz bass, wide-open harmonies, etc. It's hilarious, and fuckin' impressive, too. Hats off to producer Caleb Southern.

"Lullaby" ends the album in a major key, and it's the stuff of moonlight and dreams and . . . James Earl Jones (every dream has at least one piece that can't be interpreted, mind you.) It's a nice nightcap, one that goes down so easy it doesn't even register at first, although it's quickly becoming one of my favorite tracks on "Reinhold Messner."

I thank the members of Ben Folds Five for getting their shit together and giving us the rock classic I knew they could deliver.


Your name:

Subject:


Comments:

Forward a copy of this yak to the LS.n Editors

Forward a copy of this yak to this article's author

If you want to get an e-mail if someone responds to your yak, give us your address below. It won't be made public.

THE YAK SHACK


Name: josh
Subject: messner
-- Dec 6, 2002 at 2:35AM
he is stilll alive in every story explaing the fake i d's ive ever read no one seems to know if he is.....welll he is; he is 54 and a well established mountaineer

Name: Jack Mendell
Subject: UBORM Name
-- Jun 19, 2002 at 9:57PM
The 'man with a plan' is correct. The name 'Reinhold Messner' came off of fake IDs that... I believe it was Darren, but I'm not completely sure... had when he was younger. Apparently, there were a bunch of kids using the same ID- all copied from someone's original- and that original one probably used Messner because they saw his name somewhere. Interesting fact: When the BFF went to have the album released, they had no idea who Messner was, and were surprised that he was a real person. They eventually got permission from him or his estate (I'm not aware of whether or not he is still living) to use his name. And that, as they say, is that.

Name: a man with a plan
Subject: re: reinhold messner
-- Jun 10, 2002 at 3:32AM
sure, this is a year later than the initial inquiry, and long since the band broke up, but my two cents on the name of the album: I heard that Reinhold Messner was the name that one of the band mate;s used when he was younger on a fake ID. The actual person by the name reinhold messner was just a coincidence. Maybe this explanation is just another rumor, but it makes sense.

Name: scott
Subject: Reinhold Messner
-- Mar 6, 2001 at 8:09PM
Actually, Reinhold Messner is the greatest alpine climber ever to walk the face of this planet. He was the first man to climb all 14 of the world's 8,000 meter peaks, the first to climb the highest mountain on each continent, and the first to climb Mt. Everest without supplemental oxygen. He also was the first man to solo more than fifty of the world's mountains, including Mt. Everest. Unfortunately, he also was surrounded by much criticism over the death of his brother, Gunther, on Nanga Parbat in (I believe) 1970. Some people actually accused him of being responsible for the tragedy. So I find it quite difficult to understand why a rock band from Carolina would name their album after an Austrian climber who grew up in Italy and was never a figure in the American public to begin with...Scott

Name: The Editors Respond
Subject: Re: Reinhold Messner
-- Mar 6, 2001 at 7:53PM
Messner was a mountain climber & cartographer. No one, Ben Folds included, knows why the album has this name.

Name: scott
Subject: Reinhold Messner
-- Mar 6, 2001 at 7:51PM
Who is Reinhold Messner and why is this album dedicated to him?

Name: BLiND
Subject: Rock Classicism
-- Jul 29, 1999 at 5:20AM
Well, I'd have to agree with you on the choice of the word masterpiece, but I don't think it has anything to do with rock. The album for me is a classic in terms of clearly elucidating the psyche of a life spent in the South, specifically the Carolinas. I actually like "Army" for that reason. There is a undeniable sweetness and tender sadness that permeates the protagonist whether he succeeds or fails in escaping NC. Read the liner notes for Chrissakes, and how he got the name of the album. Humor, irony, & nostalgia, feelings that make up the bulk of my family reunions at Holden Beach, NC. "Your Most Valuable Possession" or "Your Redneck Past" both epitomize this longing to change fate and leave town, or sink into the couch on the front porch and listen to Allman Bros. ballads with a cold Schlitz.


This page is best viewed with the latest version of the Netscape or Microsoft Internet Explorer browser.

© Copyright 1998-2001 LeisureSuit Media, LLC, All Rights Reserved.
Some content is copyrighted by the author and is used with permission. No portion of this page or its content may be reproduced, in part or in whole, electronically, in print, or in any other form or by any other means, without the written consent of the LeisureSuit.net editors. Contact us at webmaster@leisuresuit.net.
[an error occurred while processing this directive]